SUMMARY & RECOMMENDATIONS
AWAAZ – SOUTH ASIA WATCH LTD. LONDON, 2004
Violent hate politics against Muslim and Christian
minorities has grown massively in India in recent years. This resulted
in the death of 2,000 people, mostly Muslims, and the displacement
of 200,000 more in the state of Gujarat in 2002. Victims included British
citizens. The ideology behind this hate-driven politics is called ‘Hindutva.’ The
organization at the core of Hindutva activities is the extremist, paramilitary,
Fascist-inspired Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). The RSS is dedicated
to turning India from a secular democratic multi-religious society
into an authoritarian anti-minority ‘Hindu nation’. Gandhi’s murderer
was an RSS activist. The RSS and its family of closely-allied organizations
have been repeatedly indicted over several decades by international
and Indian human rights organizations, judicial commissions and official
bodies for their role in large scale violence and hatred against minority
groups, including the Gujarat pogroms in 2002. The report demonstrates
that
- The extremist RSS’s front organizations have received
millions of pounds raised from the British public. These funds were
collected by the Leicester-based registered charity, Hindu Swayamsevak
Sangh (HSS) and its fundraising arm Sewa International.
- HSS and Sewa International are UK branches of the
RSS and the main purpose of their fundraising is to channel money
to extremist RSS fronts in India, despite their claim to be non-sectarian,
non-religious, non-political and purely humanitarian organizations
(see Box 1).
- Sewa International’s deep connections with the extremist
RSS were not made known to donors and the British public who gave
funds in good faith for Indian humanitarian causes. These connections
were also unknown to patrons of Sewa International appeals (see Box
1, Box 2).
- The overwhelming bulk of funds HSS and Sewa International
collected from the British public in the name of charity, including
for humanitarian relief after the Gujarat earthquake in 2001 and
the Orissa cyclone in 1999, were given to extremist RSS fronts in
India (see Box 2).
- RSS allies funded from UK public donations include
groups directly involved in large scale violence and the promotion
of hatred (see Box 3). Funds from the UK intended for disaster relief
were used to expand and glorify the hate-driven RSS’s networks in
India (see Box 2).
The report recommends that
- The charitable status of HSS and other associated
charities should be withdrawn and public sector funding and political
patronage of these organizations should end (see Box 4).
BOX 1 HINDU SWAYAMSEVAK SANGH (HSS) IS THE UK BRANCH OF THE RSS MAIN
PURPOSE OF SEWA INTERNATIONAL IS TO RAISE FUNDS FOR RSS PROJECTS EXTENT
OF DEEP RSS CONNECTION NOT MADE PUBLIC
- The Leicester-based HSS, a registered charity, is
a branch of the Indian RSS. It runs about 70 weekly physical and ideological
training cells in the UK. The HSS is modelled on the RSS, actively
promotes RSS ideology and shares the RSS aim of turning India into
an exclusive ‘Hindu nation’. The RSS in India considers the HSS to
be its UK branch. The Vishwa Hindu Parishad UK and the Kalyan Ashram
Trust UK, both registered charities, are also branches of the RSS family
operating in the UK. The full report details numerous, extensive, deep
and active connections between the HSS and the RSS.
- Sewa International is the fundraising arm of the HSS.
The main purpose of Sewa International is to raise funds from the British
public for RSS projects in India. Sewa International and the HSS have
misled donors, the public and patrons about their long-standing, deep
and committed relationship with the Indian RSS. Neither Sewa International
nor the HSS informed donors and the public that their donations were
used almost exclusively to support RSS front organizations, and that
the main purpose of HSS and Sewa International fundraising is to channel
money to these RSS fronts.
- Funds raised by Sewa International from British donors
and the public have run into millions of pounds. The overwhelming bulk
of these funds have been channelled to RSS front organizations.
- Sewa International is not a registered charity. It
uses the charity registration number of the HSS to raise funds from
the British public.
BOX 2 EARTHQUAKE FUNDS FROM BRITISH PUBLIC USED
TO EXPAND RSS NETWORKS & GLORIFY THE RSS VAST BULK OF PUBLIC FUNDS
WERE GIVEN BY SEWA INTERNATIONAL TO RSS FRONTS
- An alarming chain links unsuspecting British donors
to the active political promotion and glorification of the RSS. Charitable
funds raised by Sewa International from the British public have been
directly used to expand RSS institutions and networks in India, to
further the aims, objectives and activities of RSS organizations, and
to glorify the RSS and its leaders. Sewa International’s activities
around both the Gujarat earthquake (2001) and the Orissa cyclone (1999)
demonstrate a pattern in which a natural, human tragedy is used to
enable the dramatic expansion of RSS institutions through the use of
overseas funds. Gujarat earthquake 2001
- In key Gujarat earthquake fundraising appeals, Sewa
International did not disclose its associations with the HSS or the
RSS and it did not state that it was fundraising exclusively for RSS
affiliates. This misled British donors and public, most of whom would
have been horrified by the RSS’s history, ideology and activities.
- All £2 million raised from the British public by Sewa
International for Gujarat earthquake reconstruction and rehabilitation
from 2001 was for a major RSS affiliate, Sewa Bharati. Sewa Bharati
is dedicated to creating an exclusive Hindu nation. Sewa Bharati’s
reconstruction work was directly related to furthering the RSS’s political
agenda, including through the organization of RSS cells. A key pattern
found was that Sewa International funded Sewa Bharati for rebuilding
work, but it was the RSS that conducted ceremonies for the start of
rebuilding work or handed over the completed village to residents.
- One rebuilt village (Chapredi) included an important
dedication plaque glorifying the RSS, its founder and a key RSS affiliate.
A Hindu temple topped with saffron flags was built in the village.
No evidence was found of Sewa International funding the building of
mosques or churches, though many of these were destroyed in the earthquake.
- The RSS supreme leader K. S. Sudarshan undertook the
foundation stone laying ceremony for one village (Mithapasvaria). The
new village was handed over to residents by senior RSS leaders. The
RSS supreme leader K. S. Sudarshan undertook the opening ceremony for
another village (Rapar) during which he urged residents to expand the
RSS network in the area. Funds were raised for this village through
a multicultural event in the UK. RSS physical and ideological training
cells were started by Sewa Bharati during the rebuilding and rehabilitation
period for another village (Badanpur).
- Sewa International claimed to fund the reconstruction
of anywhere from 10 to 25 villages. It also claimed to have totally
funded the reconstruction of 10 villages. Six villages were found in
which Sewa International funds were used for reconstruction and rehabilitation.
Other fundraising
- A large proportion of the £260,000 raised by Sewa
International for Orissa cyclone relief (1999) went to enable the expansion
of major RSS affiliates. Funds were used for building RSS schools.
The RSS and its leaders were glorified. The HSS said Orissa cyclone
funds would be channelled through RSS volunteers and given to organizations
which get their workforce from the RSS.
- The extremely close involvement of the RSS, its supreme
leader and its senior figures, as well as the blatant promotion and
glorification of the RSS in both the Gujarat earthquake and Orissa
cyclone work, is sufficient to raise questions regarding Indian legal
regulations that prohibit the RSS from receiving overseas funds.
- The main education projects for which Sewa International
raises funds from the British public are RSS and VHP-run. These extremist
education projects have a political purpose for the RSS and the VHP,
a fact not disclosed by Sewa International to donors or the public.
Funds raised by Sewa International’s ‘education aid’ wing are significant,
running into hundreds of thousands of pounds.
- Each of the ‘supported projects’ for which Sewa International
raises funds from the British public is an RSS project or is linked
to the RSS.
- Sewa International raises funds from the British public
for ‘one-teacher schools’. These are extremist political projects run
by the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, Vanvasi Kalyan Ashram, Sewa Bharati,
Vidya Bharati and other RSS / VHP affiliates.
- Over a three year period, we found mentioned in HSS
UK literature a small amount of a few thousand pounds donated by Sewa
International to non-Indian causes.
BOX 3 SEWA INTERNATIONAL FUNDS ORGANIZATIONS INVOLVED OR IMPLICATED
IN VIOLENCE SEWA INTERNATIONAL FUNDS ORGANIZATIONS INVOLVED IN HATRED
- Funds raised by Sewa International have been given
to RSS organizations in India whose members and followers have been
involved or implicated in large scale anti-minority violence or religious
hatred, despite Sewa International’s denials.
- Sewa International and the Kalyan Ashram Trust UK
(a registered charity) raise funds for the RSS arm, Vanvasi Kalyan
Ashram (VKA), which has been responsible for considerable violence
and hatred against Christian and Muslim groups, including during the
Gujarat carnage in 2002.
- Sewa Bharati, the key recipient of Sewa International
Gujarat earthquake funds had its license to operate in Madhya Pradesh
revoked by the state government because of alleged violence against
Christians. Allegations of violence against Christians by Sewa Bharati
in Madhya Pradesh continue.
- Some Gujarat earthquake appeal funds collected by
Sewa International from the British public were for the RSS-allied
Lok Kalyan Samiti in Chanasma village, which has been implicated in
the violent ‘cleansing’ of all Muslims from the village and the illegal
occupation of premises and land previously under the charge of the
statutory Muslim waqf board.
- Some Gujarat earthquake appeal funds collected by
Sewa International from the British public were for the RSS’s Border
Jankalyan Samiti in Gujarat. The Jankalyan Samiti’s Maharashtra branch
was responsible for attacks on Christian organizations.
- Sewa International also raises funds for projects,
such as ‘one-teacher schools’, that involve the Vishwa Hindu Parishad
(VHP), an Indian organization at the forefront of anti-minority violence
and hatred in India. The purpose of these schools is to oppose Christians
and what the RSS calls ‘subversion’ and ‘anti-national’ tendencies.
- Almost a quarter of Sewa International earthquake
funds raised from the British public were for building sectarian, highly
controversial RSS schools. These schools are mainly run by the RSS’s
Vidya Bharati, whose teaching material has been condemned by India’s
statutory National Council for Educational Research and Training as
blatantly promoting bigotry, fanaticism and hatred.
- There are serious allegations that the RSS discriminated
against Muslims and dalits in earthquake relief, and that the RSS and
its allies attacked and intimidated secular NGOs undertaking relief
work. Earthquake relief work by RSS allies was accompanied by violence
and hatred against Christians.
- Despite their repeated claims to be non-sectarian
and non-discriminatory, Sewa International, the HSS or the VHP UK did
not launch any humanitarian appeal following the Gujarat carnage in
2002 carried out by Hindutva supremacist groups in which 2,000 people
died, mostly Muslims, and over 200,000 citizens of India were displaced.
BOX 4
RECOMMENDATIONS
Because of their role in funding, promoting or
glorifying RSS organizations that have been directly responsible
for or implicated in serious, large scale sectarian violence, hatred
or violation of human rights in India:
- The charitable status of Hindu Swayamsevak Sangh
UK, Vishwa Hindu Parishad UK and Kalyan Ashram Trust UK (all branches
of the extremist RSS family) be withdrawn by the UK Charity Commission.
- The Charity Commission take appropriate action
against the trustees of HSS. HSS / Sewa International fundraising
appeals for Indian causes were not transparent and did not disclose
to the public that funds were being raised for and sent to extremist
and sectarian RSS organizations.
- Donors and the public refuse to give funds to
the HSS, Sewa International, the VHP UK and their allied organizations.
- Politicians, public and voluntary sector organizations,
religious and community groups publicly dissociate from the HSS,
the VHP UK and their allied organizations.
NOTE ON METHODS
The report is based on
- Site visits to Gujarat villages in September 2003
- Interviews in Gujarat from March – May 2003
- Interviews in the UK, US and other parts of India
during 2003
- Analysis of paper and electronic documents, mostly
from Hindutva organizations.
|